Novels/Collections
Edited anthologies
Short works
Novels/Collections : reviews
Valdemar (series)
Series review:
Fantasy elements:
empathy, telepathy, mages, gods and goddesses, magic spirit horses
The earlier books tend to be focussed on one, or maybe two, major
viewpoints, whereas the later ones try to tell a more complicated story
with several viewpoints. I find this approach too jarring, as I get jolted
from scene to scene, and lose my immersion in the story. The latest books
still have multiple viewpoints, but seem to manage the transitions a bit
more smoothly. But I still hanker for the earlier, simpler structures.
The saga seems to be regaining some previous form with Storm
Warning and The Black Gryphon
(with Larry Dixon) after the disappointing Winds
trilogy. Some plot elements keep cropping up (no problem if you are
a fan of those plot elements), as summarised in the hilarious
filk song
"A Funny Thing Happened On The Way
To Valdemar"
Mage Wars (series)
Series review:
Skandranon and Amberdrake's tale
Unlike the other Valdemar series, the three books comprising The
Mage Wars don't form a single-story trilogy: they are three novels
linked by the same major characters, but each book is a complete story,
and each is on a completely different scale or action (Black Gryphon:
major war and historical event of lasting significance; White Gryphon:
murder mystery in a foreign culture; Silver Gryphon: two isolated
characters coming of age).
Series rating: 3
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. The Black Gryphon. Daw. 1994
Rating: 3
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Tells the tale of the pre-(Valdemar)-historic war between the mages Urtho and Ma'ar, which finally ended in a Cataclysm
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. The White Gryphon. Daw. 1995
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
The survivors of the Cataclysm have found a sanctuary, but must now make peace with the local rulers. A series of murders makes this difficult, since Skandranon is the main suspect.
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. The Silver Gryphon. Daw. 1996
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 6 July 1997
Tadrith, son of the gryphons Skandranon and Zhaneel, and Silverblade,
daughter of the humans Amberdrake and Winterhart, are feeling smothered
living in their famous parents' shadows in the cliff city of White
Gryphon. So when their first posting as Silvers, to a far-away outpost,
comes through, they are delighted: freedom at last! But they never make it
that far: something drains away their magic, and they crash, injured,
lost, and unable to call for help, in a deep forest, stalked by an unknown
enemy. Are their parents' worst fears for their safety about to become
reality?
The Silver Gryphon is essentially a rites-of-passage story;
unlike many such, the protagonists start out fully trained and competent,
but they do still have some conflicts to be resolved, with themselves,
with each other, but mainly with their parents. And, naturally, the peril
in which they find themselves helps them to do this.
The multiple viewpoints, a feature I have complained about in the past,
are handled much better here. There aren't too many changes, given the
restricted cast, and when there are, the linking is smooth enough that the
change didn't jar me out of the story. I found the ending a little rushed,
and just a little too easy, but on the whole this was an enjoyable read.
Last Herald Mage (series)
Series review:
Vanyel's tale
Series rating: 3
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mercedes Lackey. Brightly Burning. Daw. 2001
Vows and Honor (series)
Series review:
Tarma and Kethry's tale
Series rating: 2.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mercedes Lackey. Oathblood. Daw. 1998
Rating: 3
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 5 April 1998
Various Tarma and Kethry short stories have appeared in print, scattered
mainly through Marion Zimmer Bradley's
Sword and Sorceress
anthologies. Here they are collected together for the first time, along
with two new stories. Some of the stories are quite slight, others are
amusing, and one at least is essential reading for Tarma and Kethry fans:
"Sword-sworn" tells how it all began.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Sword-sworn. 1985
- How Tarma became Sword-sworn after the massacre of her clan, how she met Kethry and her geas-sword Need, and how they became she'enedra. An uncommon "rape and revenge" tale.
-
A Tale of Heroes. 1987
- The duo arrive just too late to slay a human-eating monster themselves, but need to rescue a chambermaid from the monstrous 'hero'.
-
Keys. 1988
- Kethry must unravel a locked-room mystery while Tarma faces trial by combat.
-
The Making of a Legend. 1990
- Leslac finally catches up with the mercenary duo, in order to record one of their heroic deeds firsthand. But not all deeds are the stuff of ballad.
-
The Talisman. 1990
- Kethry meets an old schoolmate who, tragically, has never accepted that magic requires hard work, not special talismans.
-
Wings of Fire. 1991
- The duo fight a sorceress who wants to enslave a Hawkbrother's firebirds.
-
A Woman's Weapon. 1992
- Tarma and Kethry intervene in a dispute between two Master Tanners.
-
Friendly Fire. 1993
- The tale of a bad-luck charm.
-
Turnabout. 1986
-
The (slightly different) story behind Bard Leslac's song Threes,
telling how Tarma, Kethry and the kyree Warrl (here referred to
as a wolf) defeat a gang of pack train bandits, and wreak a poetically
just revenge on the leader.
-
Spring Plowing at Forst Reach. 1998
- Tarma, Jodi and Beaker travel to Valdemar to train, or rather, gentle, horses the Shin'a'in way.
-
Oathblood. 1998
- Kethry's oldest daughter Jadrie swears blood oath with the twins Kira and Meri. Kethry thinks she is too young to know the seriousness of the oath, but events soon prove otherwise.
Mercedes Lackey. Exile's Honor. Daw. 2002
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 30 April 2005
Herald Alberich's tale
The story of how Karsite Captain Alberich was Chosen, became the
Herald's Weaponsmaster, and fought in the Tedrel wars that saw Selenay
become Queen.
Another book filling in the backstory of Valdemar. Alberich is Chosen
right at the start, so we get straight into Heralds and trianing. It's
mainly from Alberich's viewpoint, so is nicely focussed, and has some
interesting twists on things that we know will happen from the Talia
stories. A good account of an honorable man struggling to retain his
honour in compliated circumstances (although slightly marred by the fact
that he figures out how to do so without compromise).
Mercedes Lackey. Exile's Valor. Daw. 2003
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 1 May 2005
The second part of Herald Alberich's tale is set during the early part
of Seleny's reign, where she struggles to cope with the loss of her
father, and then her disasterous marriage to Karath.
Told mostly from Alberich's viewpoint, and partly from Seleny's, this
again offers some interesting details on the backstory known from the
Talia tales. It has more of Alberich's counter-espionage activities, and a
suprising love interest. Knowing who the villain really is, and knowing
that he won't be uncovered (at least yet!) diffuses some of the tension,
but also allows for some knowing little winks at the way people are being
decieved.
Mercedes Lackey. Take a Thief. Daw. 2001
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 21 August 2004
Skif's tale
This fills in the backstory of how ex-thief Herald Skif was Chosen.
About the first two-thirds show him training to be a thief, and the series
of tragedies that befall him. Then, once chosen, he and Alberich team up
to expose a slaving ring.
This is mostly of interest if you've already read the Talia trilogy.
Otherwise some of the sly little references to a major villan will lose
their significance, and some of the backstory details will be missed. And
it's pleasantly free of some of the problems of late 1990s Lackey books:
too many viewpoints, and too many preachy internal monologues.
Heralds of Valdemar (series)
Series review:
Queen's Own Talia's tale
Series rating: 2.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mercedes Lackey. By the Sword. Daw. 1991
Rating: 2.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Kerowyn's tale
This links Tarma and Kethry's story with the Heralds of
Valdemar: Kerowyn is Kethry's granddaughter, and this is her story of how
she ends up in Valdemar.
Although only a single book (if fat), it reads like it was planned as a
trilogy. I think it would have been better as one; it's a bit rushed in
places. However, it does mean all the action is packed in well, and the
single viewpoint makes it flow well.
Mage Winds (series)
Series review:
Elspeth's tale
Series rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mage Storms (series)
Series review:
Karal's tale
Series rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mercedes Lackey. Storm Warning. Daw. 1994
Rating: 3
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
A series of inexplicable Mage Storms are sweeping Valdemar. Karal, a
young Karsite priest, and various other characters, form an uneasy
Alliance in Valdemar, to try and solve the problem of the Storms before
they destroy their world.
Mercedes Lackey. Storm Rising. Orion. 1995
The Mage Storms are getting worse. The story is told from four main
viewpoints: Karal trying to be taken seriously as Karse Ambassador,
An'desha coming to terms with his memories and his magic, Firestorm having
problems with An'desha's remoteness, and Tremane trying to consolidate his
position in Hardorn.
Mercedes Lackey. Storm Breaking. Orion. 1996
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 3 August 1997
The desperate measures taken at the end of Storm Rising have
abated the Cataclysm echo storms for a while, giving everyone a breathing
space to consolidate, and prepare for the final trial.
The story structure has three parallel strands: Karal in Urtho's Tower,
Elspeth in Hardorn, and Heir Melles in the Empire. Yet again, I found this
plot style very off-putting. Multiple strand plots can work: in
some of David Weber's Honor Harrington
novels, for example, at times the viewpoint can flicker back and forth at
the paragraph level. The trick there is to have the various sub-plots
illuminate and give depth to the main one. But here, the strands truly are
parallel; they never really meet, and there is no main focus. Maybe in an
attempt to tell a more complex tale, too many characters get their own
time on stage for their own little stories, and nothing gels. This doesn't
have to be the case: the 'Queen's Own' trilogy has
many very memorable characters, but their stories support Talia's, rather
than detracting from it. For example, Elspeth as a character is to me much
more real from that trilogy than from the Mage Winds
or this Mage Storms ones, even though she has a
much greater role in the latter.
And again, the resolution is just too easy.
Owl (series)
Series review:
???'s tale
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. Owlflight. Daw. 1997
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. Owlsight. Daw. 1998
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. Owlknight. Daw. 1999
Mercedes Lackey, Rosemary Edghill. Spirits White as Lightning. Baen. 2002
Mercedes Lackey, Rosemary Edghill. Beyond World's End. Baen. 2000
Bardic Voices (series)
Series review:
Series rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Mercedes Lackey. Four and Twenty Blackbirds. Voyager/HarperCollins. 1997
Rating: 5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 25 October 1998
Has Mercedes Lackey forgotten how to plot? Too much turgid,
tedious build-up, to a decidedly unsatisfactory 'climax' that
disappointingly fizzled out in a few pages.
Tal Rufen, a constable, High Bishop Ardis, a Justiciar Mage, and Vysir,
a Haspur birdman, are hunting a gruesome serial killer. Yawn. We get four
viewpoints -- a few chapters of each character, but never building to any
real climax, and then swapping to another viewpoint, which starts building
background all over again. The structure put me in mind of a joke...
Syllabus for a detective story written by a physics
professor
- Origins of Law in Babylon
- Constitution of the United States
- Basic Organisation of Police Department
- Elements of Courtroom Practice
- Theory of Fingerprints.
...
- (Last Page) The Corpse
(Solution Left to the Student)
-- A. E. S. Green, American
Journal of Physics
as quoted in More
Random Walks in Science
...but this wasn't as funny. And those little italicised internal
monologues that show a character's state of mind, which were used
sparingly and worked rather well in earlier books, are now becoming
ubiquitous, preachy, and irritating.
Darkover (series)
Series review:
Tales of life under the 'bloody sun' of Darkover, a lost human colony,
reverted to feudalism, where some humans have interbred with the natives
to produce the Comyn, a psi-caste of rulers. The series ranges right from
the original Landfall, through the Ages of Chaos where the new psi powers
lead to devastating wars, through to the crisis of recontact with
mainstream, relatively alien, Terrans.
The early books in the series are okay romps
(and are probably half a point lower than the overall series rating),
but in 1975 with Heritage
of Hastur something changed, and they improved, and deepened,
dramatically (and most of these are probably half a point higher than the overall series rating).
The focus of plots varies widely throughout the series, but
they are known for dealing sensitively with the intense intimacy between
husband and wife brought by psi-contact, with homosexual relations, both
male and female, with the place of women in a feudal society, with the use
and abuse of power, with culture shock.
Series rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
Marion Zimmer Bradley, Mercedes Lackey. Rediscovery. DAW. 1993
Mercedes Lackey. The Fire Rose. Baen. 1995
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 3 November 1996
A retelling of Beauty and the Beast, set in 1905 California,
where 'Beast', Jason Cameron, is a fire magician who is stuck
half-transformed into a wolf, and 'Beauty', Rosalind (Rose) Hawkins, is a
medieval scholar he employs to help him with the research he needs to
transform himself back.
I enjoyed reading it, and found it a good page turner, but felt it was
strangely unsatisfying once I had finished it. What's there is done well,
but there are some guns carefully placed on the wall that either fail to
go off at all, or go off with only a small pop. (The Chinese magician
carefully warns Rose that the drugs might give her vivid bad dreams, but
we hear no more about this; du Mond's massive betrayal seems to have no
importance except as a minor plot device to get Rose into the wrong place
at the wrong time; and the earthquake is rather underused.)
Mercedes Lackey. The Serpent's Shadow. Daw. 2001
Mercedes Lackey. The Gates of Sleep. Daw. 2002
reimagining "Sleeping Beauty"
Mercedes Lackey. Phoenix and Ashes. Daw. 2003
Mercedes Lackey. The Wizard of London. Daw. 2005
reimagining "The Snow Queen"
Mercedes Lackey. Reserved for the Cat. Daw. 2007
reimagining "Puss in Boots"
Marion Zimmer Bradley, Andre Norton, Mercedes Lackey. Tiger Burning Bright. Avon. 1995
Rating: 6
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 5 September 1998
The city of Merina is rich and undefended, and falls prey to the
conquering Emperor Balthasar, his dark mage Apolon, and his heir Leopold.
The dowager queen Adele, her daughter queen Lydana, and the heir Shelyra
surrender the city to save it from destruction, but go underground to
fight back against the conquerors.
Ho hum. I said the Eight Dreadful Words
on page 179, and stopped reading, when I got too bored just waiting for
something to happen. By this stage we've had lots of background
introductory material, on the three Merinan women, the three enemy men,
and various other 'colourful' characters. But that's all we've had
(apart from a little heavy-handed foreshadowing about evil gems), it's
nearly half-way into the book, and I'm bored.
Maybe the problem is that each of the three writers has provided
one book's worth of build-up, all lumped together? Or maybe the problem is
that I don't like the kind of plot structure where things get worse, and
worse, and worse, and ... until, finally, the characters do
something. Maybe the writers are trying to draw a picture of a situation
so bad that even the 'ordinary' folk will revolt; I'm just sitting there
saying "what are you waiting for: fight back, dammit!"
Mercedes Lackey. Firebird. Tor. 1996
Rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 9 November 1997
Ilya Ivanovitch is one of eight hulking sons of a minor Russian Tsar.
The father is a greedy, brutish man who is afraid his sons will band
together to overthrow him, so encourages them to fight against each other
instead. Ilya seems to be the only one of the eight who has any brains,
and he longs to be out of his miserable situation. But when he catches
sight of the mythical Firebird visiting his father's orchard, his luck
just gets worse. Eventually he is forced to leave home, and goes in search
of adventure. Naturally, he comes across an evil sorceror who is holding
captive a beautiful enchanted princess. Ilya resolves to rescue her, but
needs the Firebird to help him in his quest.
The Russian mythology and history seem to be captured well here,
although in some places the decriptive detail reads more like a shopping
list or catalogue than a story. And that story is very slow to get going.
It is more than halfway through the book before Ilya even leaves home, and
yet the denoument is crammed into the last few pages.
Ilya himself is well drawn, but doesn't evoke my sympathy, despite, I
suspect, the best efforts of the author. He is certainly very put upon,
bullied by his brothers, despised by the servants. But it is made quite
clear that he in no timid weakling, and has more brains than the rest put
together, so one might feel he could have managed rather better than he
does. And all the other characters, even the all-important Firebird, are
disappointingly peripheral and two dimensional. However, it is good to see
a hero using his wits, and in a rather unconventional manner, rather than
just brute stength, to win the day.
Mercedes Lackey. Fiddler Fair. Baen. 1998
Rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 16 April 1998
A variable collection of Lackey's non-Valdemar short fiction, some
stand-alone, some set in 'sharecropped' universes and themed anthologies.
(My favorite is "Last Rights".) It includes two stories about
the mage Mertis and her bodyguard Lyran, that could have some potential if
expanded into a novel.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
How I Spent My Summer Vacation. 1998
- (essay)
-
Aliens Ate My Pickup. 1998
- A canny farmer is visited by aliens.
-
Small Print. 1994
- Read the small print if you make a pact with the Devil, especially if you are a Fundamentalist preacher.
-
Last Rights. 1993
- Animal Liberationists Free the Dinosaurs. But what if the dinosaurs don't understand the rules?
-
Dumb Feast. 1993
- A Victorian widower is pining for his dead wife. But when he finally Summons her, she isn't quite as he remembered.
-
Dance Track. 1989
- Alternate history: Isadora Duncan as a racing driver.
-
Jihad. 1993
- Alternate history: Lawrence of Arabia wins.
-
Balance. 1988
- Martis the mage is unimpressed with her new bodyguard Lyran, but needs is help with an old pupil gone rogue.
-
Dragon's Teeth. 1988
- Martis and Lyran travel to Lyosten, where the magic seems out of control.
-
The Cup and the Cauldron. 1992
- The old Celtic ways and the newly arrived Christianity have something in common after all.
-
Once and Future. 1995
- A modern day Pendragon is offered the chance to Save the World.
-
Fiddler Fair. 1989
- (Originally written for Andre Norton's Magic in Ithkar anthology; later fixed up as an episode in The Lark and the Wren.) Rune competes for a place in the male-dominated Minstrel's Guild.
-
The Enemy of My Enemy. 1989
- (From Robert Adams' Friends of the Horseclans anthology.) The last remaining gypsies meet the Horseclans, and the 'Dirteater' settlers.
Mercedes Lackey. The Black Swan. Daw. 1999
Mercedes Lackey. Werehunter. Baen. 1999
Rating: 3.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 12 December 1999
Another collection of Lackey's short fiction (one set in her Valdemar
universe), some stand-alone, some set in 'sharecropped' universes and
themed anthologies.
The four stories about SKitty have a slightly old-fashioned air -- one
could imagine them fixed up into a pleasing 1950s-esque space opera novel.
(They also don't read too well one after the other, because of the
scene-setting recapitulations in the later ones.) My favorite story is "Operation
Desert Fox", set in the Bolo universe. This despite the fact there is
a Valdemar story here -- of Alberich's being Chosen. Lackey says this is
the only Valdemar short story she has done, because she hates "to
waste a good idea on something as small as a short story" -- and I
think she's right; the novel (or maybe even trilogy) is her best length
(but only when she makes that length up from incidents concerning the main
protagonist, not when padding with too many subordinate stories).
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Werehunter. 1987
-
(Set in Andre Norton's Witch World
universe.) Glenda is offered escape from her intolerable life, into a
world where she is a were-leopard. Her life gets much better, until the
villagers put a werehunter on her trail.
-
Nightside. 1989
- Urban witch Diana Tregard and her vampire lover Andre must stop a soul-killer.
-
SKitty. 1991
- Dick White and his gene-tailored shipscat SKitty solve a trading problem on Lacu'un
-
A Tail of Two SKitties. 1994
- Dick White and SKitty foil a hostile takeover bid
-
SCat. 1996
- Dick White discovers where SKitty's mate came from
-
A Better Mousetrap. 1999
- Dick White discovers that not everyone on Lacu'un likes shipscats
-
The Last of the Season. 1994
- A paedophile chooses the wrong victim
-
Satanic, Versus .... 1990
- Diana Tregard must cope with the results of a "whoopie witch" summoning "tall dark and handsome" but forgetting to add "human"
-
Wet Wings. 1995
- The world has grown too politically correct to tolerate Katherine's differences.
-
Stolen Silver. 1991
- How Alberich was Chosen, and his arrival in Valdemar
-
Roadkill. 1990
- Why did that cardboard box blow against the wind?
-
Operation Desert Fox. 1993
- Retired soldier Siegfried O'Harrigan, and obsolete Bolo tank RML-1138 team up on backwater planet Bachman's World.
-
Grey. 1997
- Sarah's pet and protector, Grey the parrot, is left behind in Africa when she goes to school in London. But she needs his protection more than ever.
-
Grey's Ghost. 1999
- Sarah, Grey, and Killian investigate a medium.
Mercedes Lackey. Joust. Daw. 2003
Mercedes Lackey. The Fairy Godmother. Daw. 2004
Rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 3 February 2007
In the Five Hundred Kingdoms, the Tradition is always hard at work,
trying to make everyone's life fit a fairy tale. But there are only so
many Sleeping Princesses, or Noble Princes, to go around. So Elena Klovis,
ground down by her wicked stepmother and two cruel sisters, awaits her
prince. But he's only 11, and so completely unsuitable. But eventually,
her Fairy Godmother turns up to help, in a rather unexpected way.
This is a fun play on the traditions of fairy tales, but a bit
disjointed, with rather a lot of incidents packed in. But it manages to
subvert a few cliches as Elena battles with the Tradition in novel ways,
and moves steadily on to its own Happy Ever After.
Mercedes Lackey. One Good Knight. Daw. 2006
Rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 17 February 2007
The bookish Princess Andromeda of Acadia is the only one who knows what
needs to be done when a dragon appears and starts terrorising the
countryside: it needs to be appeased by a weekly virgin sacrifice. But
when she reports to her mother the rumours that the lottery is rigged, she
is horrified to discover that she is to be the next sacrifice.
Determined not to go quietly, she plots her escape, only to see the dragon
frightened off by the Champion Sir George. Both are aware that at this
point the Tradition decrees Andromeda should fall in love with her
rescuer: both are determined that won't happen. But the Tradition still
demands that the dragon be defeated, so off they go on a Quest.
This is another fun romp through the land of the Five Hundred Kingdoms,
where Tradition rules your fate, and where the clever can subvert the
Tradition to their own ends. But remember, the Tradition is just as happy
with a tragedy as it is with a Happy Ever After...
Mercedes Lackey. Fortune's Fool. Luna. 2007
Rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 19 April 2008
In the Five Hundred Kingdoms, you can do quite well if you understand
what the Tradition wants. Sasha, seventh son of the king of Led Belarus,
is the Fortunate Fool, and his family knows it. So he spends his time
making his Luck work for the land. Katya, seventh daughter of the Sea
King, is his eyes and ears on secret missions. When they meet, Tradition
goes into overdrive. Katya, while investigating a transplanted Jinn, is
taken captive. While she schemes to escape from the inside, Sasha must
scheme her rescue from the outside.
This is another fun frolic through the traditions of fairy tale, this
time of Russia and Japan. In places, it seems a bit like a whirlwind tour
of Russian folktales without doing that much to advance the plot: Rusalka,
check; Baba Yaga, check. And all the captives seem to have the same name
(five letters, ends in "a", sounds like...) and not enough
personality to help me distinguish them easily. But there's enough action,
and some loose ends later tied together, to make for some amusing mind
candy.
Mercedes Lackey. The Snow Queen. Luna. 2008
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 22 February 2009
Godmother and Snow Queen, Aleksia's main job is to support the
Tradition by abducting young men about to turn bad, and putting them
through a trial to show them the error of their ways. She sometimes
worries that she is becoming as cold as her own Ice Palace. But then
come the rumours of a wicked Snow Witch, freezing whole villages to
death, and claiming to be the Snow Queen. Aleksia has to set off on
her own adventure to sort things out.
This time we have a romp through Finnish fairy tales. The route to
the climactic final trial is entertaining enough, even if feeling a
bit like a fairyland travelogue in places, but some guns on walls are
left unfired (all that unused buildup about Kaari and the forest
spirits -- or is that for a future book?), and the final showdown is
too easy and way too obvious, and is over much too soon.
Mercedes Lackey. The Sleeping Beauty. Luna. 2010
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 11 October 2011
Godmother Lily is having a hard time protecting the small but rich
kingdom of Eltaria. The Tradition is trying to force Princess Rosamund
down a path -- but is it that of Sleeping Beauty or Snow White?
Everything seems to be being subverted, from the seven evil dwarfs who
capture Rosamund, to the Wicked Stepmother who rescues her. And to top
it all, Prince Siegfried needs to rescue a maiden who isn't
his aunt from a ring of fire in order to avoid his own Doom. The only
solution to all this: issue a set of challenges to all the local
Princes, the prize being the kingdom and fair Rosamund's hand.
Another amusing romp through mangled fairy tales. Here we get
Sleeping Princesses aplenty. Lackey recommends listening to Anna
Russell summarising the story in her own inimitable fashion, in "The
Ring of the Nibelungs (An Analysis)", to help understand
some of the plot points here. (I have heard it. I thoroughly
recommend it. Be very careful if you are listening to it while
driving, however.) Some of the plot points are a bit heavy handed
(Siegfried's befriending of the animals, for example), but there are
some amusing twists and turns along the way.
Edited anthologies : reviews
Mercedes Lackey, editor. Sword of Ice: and other tales of Valdemar. Daw. 1997
Rating: 4
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 2 May 1997
Short stories tend to be 'one idea' tales, simply because of lack of
space. There is no time to develop characters or backgrounds beyond the
needs of the story. Writers in a well-known existing world have an
advantage: much of the background is already known to the readers, and can
just be assumed. Some of the authors in this Valdemar anthology take
advantage of that fact, and give us vignettes of a Herald's or
Hawkbrother's life (such as The Demon's Den, or Ironrose),
or fill in bits of history mentioned only in passing in the novels (such
as Sword of Ice or Vkandis' Own). Others, disappointingly
however, seem to have a story they want to tell, and set it in Valdemar
merely to fit into the anthology (such as A Song For No One's Mourning).
Helps to while away the time until the next Valdemar novel.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Philip M. Austin, Mercedes Lackey. Sunlancer. 1997
- A Karse captain has to question his conscience: should children be sacrificed to Vkandis?
-
Tanya Huff. The Demon's Den. 1997
- A Herald is trapped in a collapsed mine; the only person who can save him is a mining engineer badly crippled in a previous accident.
-
Larry Dixon, Mel White. Ironrose. 1997
- The hertasi conspire to bring together two lonely members of the Hawkbrother clan.
-
Josepha Sherman. Babysitter. 1997
- A stranded traveller needs all his wits to save an orphaned gryphon cub.
-
Richard Lee Byers. The Salamander. 1997
- Someone is sending fire against Mornedealth's Blue faction. Is it the hated Greens, or an unknown enemy?
-
Janni Lee Simner. A Child's Adventures. 1997
- Inya is a grandmother by the time she is Chosen, and she feels to old for adventures.
-
Stephanie D. Shaver. Blood Ties. 1997
- Unpleasant times in the life in a Border family.
-
Lawrence Schimel. ...Another Successful Experiment. 1997
- A trainee Herald invents a new game.
-
Michelle West. Choices. 1997
- Kelsey has yearned all her life to be Chosen, but never has, even though she has all the Herald virtues. Then she finds out why.
-
Kristin Schwengel. Song of Valdemar. 1997
- Revyn desperately wants to be a Bard, but he has Healer gifts instead. It takes a tragedy before he can accept his fate.
-
Elisabeth Waters. The School Up the Hill. 1997
- Quenten's White Winds school at Bolthaven is teaching weather control: is that why it's raining in the kitchen of the local inn?
-
Mark Shepherd. Chance. 1997
- Guardsman Jonne, himself shay'a'chern, meets the legendary Vanyel.
-
Mercedes Lackey, John Yezeguielian. Sword of Ice. 1997
- How Herald-Mage Savil met Hawkbrother Starwind.
-
John Helfers. In the Forest of Sorrows. 1997
- Vanyel, spirit of the Forest of Sorrows, rescues Treyon from a sorceress.
-
Ben Ohlander. Vkandis' Own. 1997
- Solaris' first miracle in Karse.
-
Mickey Zucker Reichert. A Herald's Honor. 1997
- Herald Martin has vowed to be faithful to Lyssa, then discovers he is lifebonded with Judaia. How can he reconcile his honour and his heart?
-
Gary A. Braunbeck. A Song For No One's Mourning. 1997
- Olias is a bitter and hardened thief, until he meets the Gifted L'lewythi.
-
Philip M. Austin, Mercedes Lackey. Blue Heart. 1997
- A Herald-assassin tells Selenay a story of a butterfly.
Mercedes Lackey, editor. Sun in Glory: and other tales of Valdemar. Daw. 2003
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 23 December 2003
A rather slight set of tales set against the background of the Valdemar
world. Some tell stories that build up the history (such as The Cat
Who Came to Dinner and Sun in Glory), but most are just a
random vignette of a day in the life of a Herald, or another way to be
Chosen. Tanya Huff's Brock is an interesting variant on this
theme, but mostly this is mind candy.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Catherine S. McMullen. Errold's Journey
-
A wizard and his apprentice escape Ma'ar and set up a new life far
away.
-
Nancy Asire. The Cat Who Came to Dinner
-
Reulan makes a pilgrimage to Karse's capital city, on the suggestion
of his cat.
-
Michelle West. Winter Death
-
Kayla has suffered one too many harsh winters, and lost one too many
kin. So why has the Companion waited until now to Choose her? And what
is the sickness gripping Valdemar?
-
Mickey Zucker Reichert. A Herald's Rescue
-
Santar is confronted by a Companion seemingly desperate for his aid
in rescuing his Herald. Santar has quite an ordeal before the end.
-
Josepha Sherman. In the Eye of the Beholder
-
Marra's family has been slaughtered by Darick, and she has escaped
into the forest, there to meet a strange monster who was once human.
They may be the answer to each other's troubles.
-
Fiona Patton. Trance Tower Garrison
-
Who is the Companion trying to reach in the besieged garrison?
-
Stephanie D. Shaver. Starhaven
-
Herald Vess has to find out how the innocent young Healer is using
blood magic, and how it is linked to the destruction of Starhaven years
earlier.
-
Judith Tarr. Rebirth
-
Herald Mage Mathias dies defending Queen Vera, but has a vision of
her losing her soul. So he breaks the rules of the Havens to save her
again. What will his punishment be?
-
Tanya Huff. Brock
-
Brock, called half-wit by the villagers, claims he is a Herald. Then
two real Heralds arrive. Their Companions are strangely supportive of
Brock.
-
Michael Longcor. True Colors
-
Rin is a con-man, and has found the best trick of all in remote
Valdemar -- to pose as a Herald. Then a bandit raid and two frightened
children put his lie to the test.
-
Brenda Cooper. Touches the Earth
-
Anya's fear is stopping her using her Healing power. Then a friend is
badly injured in a raid.
-
Rosemary Edghill. Icebreaker
-
Elidor is training as a scribe, but has always dreamed of being
Chosen. When a Companion appears, he discovers dreams don't always come
true.
-
Mercedes Lackey. Sun in Glory
-
The story of Talia's induction into the Karsite priesthood under
Solaris, the new Sun of the Son , from Alberich's PoV.
Mercedes Lackey, editor. Crossroads: and other tales of Valdemar. Daw. 2005
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 20 May 2006
Another bunch of tales set in the Valdemar universe, mostly so-so, but a
few with an interesting new take.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Larry Dixon. Transmutation
-
The gryphon Kelvren is drained of magic, dying, unless another
gryphon can be found to cure him. Meanwhile he sets about making the
most of what slim resources he remaining to inspire the Valdemar army.
-
Nancy Asire. The Feast of the Children
-
Yet another priest of V'kandis acquires a chatty cat, who helps him
save children from the flames.
-
Richard Lee Byers. Death in Keenspur House
-
Selden investigates a murder that threatens the fragile truce between
Greens and Blues in Mornedealth.
-
Brenda Cooper. Dawn of Sorrows
-
The cost to those left behind after a Choosing is finally recognised.
-
Rosemary Edghill. Horse of Air
-
Herald Paymin has had to change the manner of his service to the
Crown since his Companion was killed 20 years earlier, and now goes to
investigate reports of a witch.
-
Sarah A. Hoyt, Kate Paulk. A Change of Heart
-
Ree has been changed into a hobgoblin during the Mage Wars, and
worries he is losing his humanity, until he stumbles across Jem.
-
Tanya Huff. All the Ages of Man
-
Circumstances oblige Herald Jors to mentor the young, attractive
Herald Alyise on her Internship, but he's worried that he's too young
for the responsibility.
-
Michael Longcor. War Cry
-
A gift of empathy awakes during the final battle of the Tedrel Wars.
-
Ben Ohlander. Strength and Honor
-
A Karsite Warmaster must decide where his loyalties lie: with the
governing Black Robes, or the Priestly Red Robes.
-
Fiona Patton. The Blue Coat
-
The last survivors of the Goshon tribe hope to find a home in
Valdemar.
-
Stephanie D. Shaver. Safe and Sound
-
A novice bard desperate for inspiration for her proving song pesters
a Herald about his dead sister.
-
Janni Lee Simner. Song for Two Voices
-
A tale of a Holderkin lifebonding.
-
Mickey Zucker Reichert. Finding Elvida
-
Trainee Herald Elvida has to discover her gift for herself, before
the traumatic attack by bandits kills her and her Companion.
-
Judith Tarr. Darkwall's Lady
-
Merris is willing to honour her parent's bargain to make her heir of
Darkwall, but she wants to find out precisely what she's letting herself
in for.
-
Michael Z. Williamson. Naught but Duty
-
An honourable mercenary captain finds himself contracted to a most
dishonourable master.
-
Mercedes Lackey. Landscape of the Imagination
-
Tarma and Kethry find themselves accompanying a mage in a strange
landscape between two Gates.
Mercedes Lackey, editor. Moving Targets: and other tales of Valdemar. Daw. 2008
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 22 December 2008
Yet more tales from the Valdemar universe. Many of these are "sequels"
to tales in earlier volumes, helping to add a little depth. And many
are the usual tales of alientated Herald/Bard/Healer/whatever
nevertheless making good.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. Moving Targets
- Groan!
-
Nancy Asire. An Unexpected Guest
- How Sosha and Torgon first met
-
Brenda Cooper. The Power of Three
- The twins' bond is strong: will they survive separation?
-
Janni Lee Simner. What Fire Is
- Tamar can call fire: a dangerous ability in Karse
-
Mickey Zucker Reichert. Dreams of Mountain Clover
- Mola dreams that mountain clover will help her dying Herald mistress
-
Richard Lee Byers. The Cheat
- Selden is convinced that Dromis is helping his pupils cheat in duels: but how to prove it?
-
Kristin Schwengel. A Dream Deferred
- Laeka finda a wounded kyree, and helps rescue her stolen cubs
-
Michael Z. Williamson. The Sworddancer
- Riga has trained all her life to fight, bt finds that war is different
-
Stephanie D. Shaver. Broken Bones
- A lovesick Bard solves a local problem
-
Tanya Huff. Live On
- On the Importance of Stories
-
Rosemary Edghill. Passage at Arms
- Chosen Aellele is convinced that she won't become a Herald, because she is not a nice persons
-
Sarah A. Hoyt, Kate Paulk. Heart, Home and Herth
- Hobgoblin Ree and his human friend Jem find what looks like a deserted house to shelter in.
-
Fiona Patton. Haven's Own
- A fire puts Haven City Watch in between two fueding factions
-
Judith Tarr. Widdershins
- A Herald must put aside his own fears, and the hatred of his intern, to save a riding school.
Mercedes Lackey, editor. Changing the World: all-new tales of Valdemar. Daw. 2009
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 30 June 2010
Further short stories set in the Valdemar world. Some could be set
in any generic fantasy world, but most are extending the history of
the Heralds, as a group, and as individuals.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Mercedes Lackey. The One Left Behind
- Marya is no fan of the Heralds: first her father, then her fiancee, deserted her to become Heralds. So when two Heralds come knocking on her door for help, she is less than willing to offer it.
-
Rosemary Edghill, Denise McCune. For Want of a Nail
- The arrival of strange "Companions" at the founding of Valdemar makes the soldier Navos very suspicious.
-
Elizabeth A. Vaughan. Softly Falling Snow
- Queen Elspeth the Peacemaker looks back on her reign: was it worth the sacrifices?
-
Mickey Zucker Reichert. The Reluctant Herald
- Lubonne comes from a wealthy family and is about to marry the woman of his dreams, so the arrival of a Companion intent on Choosing him is less than welcome.
-
Elisabeth Waters. A Storytelling of Crows
- Maia's ability to talk to the animals helps her rescue a wounded Herald.
-
Kristin Schwengel. Waiting to Belong
- Shia's best friend Teo is Chosen, but her own healing skills are needed at home.
-
Brenda Cooper. The Last Part of the Way
- Twin Bard and Healer sisters accompanying a Herald devastated by the loss of his family wonder how to get him to continue with his life.
-
Stephanie D. Shaver. Midwinter Gifts
- Herald Lyle needs his Bardic twin sister Lelia to help uncover a possible serial murderer.
-
Michael Z. Williamson. Wounded Bird
- Trader Riga is appalled by the brutal treatment of women in Mirr, but what can she do?
-
Kate Paulk. Defending the Heart
- Ree and Jem's home is invaded by soldiers who carry Jem off. What can Ree do to help?
-
Sarah A. Hoyt. Matters of the Heart
- Ree and Jem feel displaced when Garrad's son returns home.
-
Tanya Huff. Nothing Better to Do
- Herald Jors has to deliver an orphaned baby to its next of kin.
-
Fiona Patton. The Thief of Anvil's Close
- Sergeant Dann of Haven City Watch investigates curious thefts from a cantankerous smith.
-
Judith Tarr. Twice Blessed
- Cousins Nerys and Kelyn have been fighting each other since birth. Then a Companion appears; which one will he Choose?
-
Nancy Asire. Be Careful What You Wish For
- A Karsian exile, now a Herald, returns home to track down his kin.
-
Ben Ohlander. Interview with a Companion
- A modern day journalist finds a fantastic new source.
Mercedes Lackey, editor. Finding the Way: and other tales of Valdemar. Daw. 2010
Rating: 4.5
[ unmissable | great stuff | worth reading | mind candy | waste of time | unfinishable ]
reviewed 1 March 2011
More short stories set in the world of Valdemar and surrounding
lands. Many of these involve characters from earlier collections,
slowly building up a richer story about them.
Contents
(possible spoilers)
-
Mercedes Lackey, Larry Dixon. Finding the Way
- Sherra the hertasi guides an impatient Companion through the swamp.
-
Rosemary Edghill, Denise McCune. In Burning Zones We Build Against the Sun
- Hedion is killing himself with all his healing, and that won't help anyone.
-
Elizabeth A. Vaughan. Unintended Consequences
- Ceraratha's husband failed to kill Queen Selenay; what will happen to her?
-
Mickey Zucker Reichert. The Education of Evita
- Evita is Chosen, but has an extremely naive world-view.
-
Elisabeth Waters. A Charm of Finches
- Maia's ability to talk to the animals helps her punish a wicked brother.
-
Kristin Schwengel. Healing in White
- Newly Chosen Shia knows more about Healing than being a Herald.
-
Brenda Cooper. Songs of a Certain Sort
- Twin Bard and Healer sisters find trouble off the beaten track.
-
Stephanie D. Shaver. Otherwise Engaged
- Lelia and Grier each love another.
-
Kate Paulk. Heart's Choice
- Ree and Jem discover a baby changeling.
-
Sarah A. Hoyt. Heart's Own
- Ree and Jem have difficulties raising Meren.
-
Tanya Huff. The Time We Have
- Herald Jors is strangely drawn to a bandit woman.
-
Fiona Patton. A Bard by Any Other Name
- Sergeant Dann of Haven City Watch investigates a poetic vandal.
-
Judith Tarr. Change of Life
- Marlys is marrying off her last daughter, and wonders who the Companion has come to Choose.
-
Nancy Asire. Lack of Vision
- Karse judge Perren tries a murder case.
-
Michael Z. Williamson, Gail Sanders. The Groom's Price
- Keth're'son has mind magic, but does not want to go to Valdemar for training.